Ethiopian Adoptee Wins Legal Case to Revoke Adoption

Marthe Van Der Wolf / voanews.com
February 11, 2013

ADDIS ABABA, ETHIOPIA — An Ethiopian court has revoked the adoption of a girl by a family in the Netherlands. This is the first time a foreign adoption has been revoked in Ethiopia’s long history of overseas adoption.

Betty Lub is a 14-year-old Ethiopian girl that was adopted at the age of seven by a Dutch family that abused her. She stayed with them for two years, but still carries their last name because of legal procedures.

Betty got the adoption revoked through an Ethiopian court. Her lawyer, Mulemebet Tilahua, said Betty now wants to change her name to Betty Demoze, her Ethiopian last name.

“Revocation of the adoption contract will have an effect on Betty and in a way she will be reinstated to her family of origins. And the other thing is, she will not be forced to be called after the adoptive parents who abused her in their home for a long time,” said Tilahua.

Falsified documents

The documents in Betty’s adoption file were falsified and were full of errors. They gave the wrong age, and wrongly stated that Betty’s parents had died. After a failed criminal case two years ago against those involved with providing the papers, the 14-year-old started a civil case.

Betty said that getting her adoption revoked in Ethiopia is only the first step of her journey.

“I want to try in Holland to also revoke my adoption and then we will see,” she said.

Almost 4,500 children were adopted from Ethiopia in 2010, with about half of them going to American families. Because a growing number of adoption cases from Ethiopia appear to have irregularities, the legal process has been under investigation in Ethiopia and other countries.

Child trafficking

Arun Dohle investigated the files of Ethiopian children going to the Netherlands for the Against Child Trafficking NGO. He said Betty’s case is just the tip of the iceberg.

“We found that the adoption process is riddled by fraud and other clear-cut criminal activities. But most important, the demand-driven inter-country adoption process is breaking up families who could be helped in building up their lives with a fraction of the money involved in inter-country adoption,” said Dohle.

Adoptions are big business in development countries, with Western parents usually paying more than $20,000 for a child. Ethiopia’s adoption business grew rapidly after several countries in the world, such as Romania and Vietnam, stopped allowing overseas adoptions because of legal irregularities and corruption.

Dohle believes that the inter-country adoption process is systematically misleading parents.

“Most of the Ethiopian and African parents in general, do not understand the Western concept of adoption, which completely severs all ties with the child. The child gets a new birth certificate a new identity, and all ties are completely severed, there is no such thing as international foster care,” said Dohle.

Preying on parents

Many parents are not told they are losing their child, they are promised financial support and are made to believe their child will receive a better education somewhere else and will return home soon.

Lawyer Mulemebet said parents in developing countries are an easy target for adoption agencies.

“Most of the time they are not aware of their legal rights and they are not in a position, especially in a financial position, to claim their rights and to ensure the best interests of their children,” said Mulemebet.

Betty was adopted through the Dutch adoption agency Wereldkinderen. It is accused of fraud and criminal activities in research done by the Against Child Trafficking group. Wereldkinderen chose not to comment on the first revoked adoption case.

Betty hopes her actions will inspire other adoptees.

“I hope that it will have impact on other children to do the same thing that I have done,” she said.

The Ethiopian Ministry of Women’s, Children’s and Youth Affairs decided in 2011 to cut adoptions by 90 percent because of fraud during the adoption processes.

0

documentary

More about this case can be watched in the documentary Children for Sale.

Illegal abusive adoption, and the legal consequence

Readers might notice this article features a  Blue Box -- this Blue Box features articles with a similar theme.  In this case, readers are able to see just how rampant illegal adoption is world-wide, and how little paying adopters react to this news.  In fact, it seems few PAPs will voice any outrage against the manufacturing of orphans until they themselves are back home with "their" (adopted) child, and secure with the belief that a finalized adoption is one that's "legal" and untouchable.  In fact, it seems a more common response from APs "horrified" to learn about illegal adoptions (and all that's done to the children to make such ICA plans possible) go along something like this:

after reading with "utter horror" the latest revelations of child trafficking in China in the Los Angeles Times, Gardner found herself contemplating a trip to back to Jiangxi province to investigate how Zoë, now 7, came up for adoption.

"I don't think I could live with myself for the rest of my life thinking that my desire to have a child could have caused tragedy in someone else's family," Gardner said. "I'm going to need answers, and for my daughter's sake as well."  [From: Trafficking reports raise heart-wrenching questions for adoptive parents, 2009 ]

If APs think THEY need answers, imagine how much adoptees need answers, WITHOUT AP censoring and sugar-coating.

I really loved this article.  I wish we had more of these reports.  To date, I only know of another adoptee who wanted to annul his own adoption (and won), and yet I can't help but believe the message coming from these brave adoptees is clear:   today's  modern day adoptees are smarter and braver than they were decades ago.  Given the amount of information about  the illegal adoption route so many APs take and then couple that with information extracted from sites like PPL, (where the archiving of abuse cases prove abusive APs exist, and these homes are dangerous places for adopted children), I feel as though there's no reason to NOT see more cases going to court.  If MORE angry adoptees speak up and out, and receive the support Betty received through NGO's like ACT, an organization determined to get word-out about illegal unethical adoptions, at least some justice will be served.

Not that rare in the Netherlands.

Dear Kerry, here a couple of Dutch revoked adoptions:

http://zoeken.rechtspraak.nl/detailpage.aspx?ljn=BN6040
http://zoeken.rechtspraak.nl/detailpage.aspx?ljn=BT8475
http://zoeken.rechtspraak.nl/detailpage.aspx?ljn=BQ6551
http://zoeken.rechtspraak.nl/detailpage.aspx?ljn=BW5040
http://zoeken.rechtspraak.nl/detailpage.aspx?ljn=BW5204

No identifying info and all in legalese Dutch, unfortunately. There were more, but they aren't all published. It has been suggested that there are about five unadoptions a year in the Netherlands, but I'm not too confident about that. With these cases already in place, the only exciting thingy in Dutch law about Betty's legal case is: Will she be free before her 20th birthday?

greatly appreciated

Thank you Theodore, the topic of Adoption Annulment is one rarely discussed, while some adoptions turn out so badly that an adult adoptee, sometimes after decades of separation decides the reminder of the adoption is more painful than going through a legal procedure.

I added the cases you found to our website, so the links to those pages can never get broken:

Dutch adoption annulment case: LJN: BQ6551
Dutch adoption annulment case: LJN: BN6040
Dutch adoption annulment case: LJN: BW5204
Dutch adoption annulment case: LJN: BT8475
Dutch adoption annulment case: LJN: BN6040

Primary links

Pound Pup Legacy